Visionary and Canceled Projects & Proposals | Discussion

@Mackensen I made this quick little overlay to show you where that old proposal was from one of your previous posts. The main building would’ve mainly taken up the footprints of, as I mentioned before, Foley Square, but also the NY County Supreme Court building, The Health Building, and The State Office Building. The park in the back would’ve taken up half of the Criminal Courts Building.

I also added blue lines to represent the streets that do still exists and as you can see, the Civic Center and its buildings really obliterated some of them.

5 Likes

Thanks you TKDV :+1:

Vision from 1925

Now follow the details of the competition of the new courthouse in New York.


From the architec George B. Post only the rendering


Floorplan

Design by Mc Kim, Mead and White


This was the design of a Chicago architectural firm.

Finally, the winning design by Guy Lowell compared to the design by George B. Post.

2 Likes

Per:City View Tower in Long Island City Set to Become Queens's First Supertall - New York YIMBY

Queens first supertall

5 Likes

That would have been nice

1 Like

was also a better design than the one we got imo. From what I can gather the blame lays entirely on the FAA for a determination of hazard to very specific situational air traffic that will never occur.

Sven was also supposed to be a 900 footer with a more NY-ish design.

7 Likes

Per: The Illinois Tower: Chicago's Mile-High 1956 Skyscraper - Malevus

2 Likes

I really like this

1 Like

4 Likes

how tall would the building be? what is it now?

https://www.instagram.com/p/CZiDAgsjfIX/

A very interesting Insta video about “The 78 Casino” proposal by KPF too bad it was not selected.

In Brooklyn

Per: Unbuilt Downtown Brooklyn Tower Reveals Block's Full Zoning Potential | CityRealty


147 Prince Street

Per: Seven unbuilt stadiums are brought to life in renderings
https://www.archpaper.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/01_Brooklyn-Dome.jpg

Per: MACY'S, BROOKLYN, NY | LEESER ARCHITECTURE | Archinect

LEESER Architecture was engaged to develop a vision for the 1.2 million sf addition on the Macy’s parcels in Downtown Brooklyn. The design features a 910 feet tall tower, and two 390 feet tall high-rises, incorporating residential functions, a commercial base of retail, and a public plaza. The iconic tower will house 230 condos and 468 rental units and is added on-top of an existing building, while preserving its Art-Deco facade. The structural design and phasing is conceived in a way that it would allow Macy’s to remain open during constructions.
A two tower mixed-use complex, designed on the opposite site of the block, provides 200,000 sf retail spaces, a public plaza, 248 condo units and 308 rental units.

Per: Vision: Plans for Downtown Brooklyn Macy's Redevelopment by Leeser Architecture and Ismael Leyva - New York YIMBY

3 Likes

In Philadelphia


Center City

2 Likes
2 Likes

image

1 Like

6 Columbus Cirle

2 Likes

Frankfurt am Main

Max Tower 230 meters and 63 floors by Helmut Jahn



Waldstadion for the WM 2006 in Germany


Credit: Frankfurt | Nie realisierte Projekte/Entwürfe/Varianten... Never realized | Page 7 | SkyscraperCity Forum

This design for the Millennium Tower by the architects Schneider and Schumacher is not the winning design of the architectural competition.



„ The design by schneider+schumacher impresses on the one hand with the relocation of the elevators into a transparent connecting structure between the two skyscrapers: The glazed joint, which extends to a height of 333 meters, makes it possible to develop a common, urban lobby with bars, restaurants and stores from the 40th to 43rd floors with comparatively little effort from the separately conceived sky lobbies for offices and hotels.“

News | schneider+schumacher

5 Likes

Per: World Trade Center

Per: The NYC That Never Was: 1 WTC and the Competition for the World Trade Center Site - Untapped New York


Per: Timeline – World Trade Center Rebuilding

2 Likes

ultimately, what we ended up getting is very close to Memorial Plaza

the charade with the second competition and Liebeskin’s so call “master plan” was just to mollify the outraged public but build the plan the developers wanted from the very beginning




63 Madison case study. © SOM | miysis

2 Likes