There is a lot of commercial and new residential property in DT BKLYN: the ‘shadow inventory’ is kept-in-the-dark - so no one knows how much excess is currently on the market.
NYC is rebound from C19 for sure, and I believe a very robust market will soon return. However, would this project vigorously more forward given the current glut in the market. I don’t see this moving forward any time soon: please correct me if you know otherwise.
But from a distance, the facade is too repetitive and monolithic. It needs something else to break up the pattern and give it more texture on the larger scale.
I think the flat, reflective glass surfaces do a good job of breaking up the relentless orthogonality of the rest of the facade. Judging from the distance render in the YIMBY article Berzerk linked a few posts up, the two facade treatments will contrast very nicely in both reflectivity and texture. Downtown Brooklyn has unfortunately seen some dire architecture recently, but I think this, 9 DeKalb, and the Jeanne Gang tower are very nice.
In my world view - aesthetically speaking - there are only 3 levels of relative merit in terms of Architectural Design: good, better, and best. The nice, nicer and nicest terms serve quite well too. This one comes in solidly as a NICER than most, a BETTER architectural design than most. There is the occasional rare exception - (not nice) or (CaCa) - but those statistical outliers are too few to mention.
This is surely a pleasing work of Architecture, not quite on the 9 Dekalb level of excellence: but quite NICE. It will be fun to watch this new building rise to great height; hopefully at least about 900 Feet.
In addition to having a nicer design (see infoshare’s post above) it’s a few blocks away from 9 Dekalb, so they won’t be competing with each other or cancel out each other’s impact on the skyline. Brooklyn will have two peaks instead of one large one.
I agree infoshare that this one looks like a winner in renders. But as I suspect you know I always wait for the real thing to make a judgment. With Dekalb I’m ready to say it’s top notch.